Saturday, 30 May 2009

Nigel Griffiths in more expense claims

Local Edinburgh South MP Nigel Griffiths is under scrutiny once again - this time for the veracity of his expense claim (which was turned down) for £3,600 to help listen to Scottish TV and radio. This piece points out that digital radio (for which he had claimed) was incapable of picking up Radio Scotland in London.

Sex in our city - the Grange Association

The spring edition of the Grange Association newsletter has an article by Tom Breheny giving an account of - sex in our city.  It is compelling.  You can find the newsletter here but you will need to scroll down to page 7 for the relevant article.

Friday, 29 May 2009

Meadows events area overuse latest

Yesterday the Council agreed not to approve new events on the Meadows until a management plan is in place.    The Lady Boys of Bangkok (Urban Circus) has already been approved and is certain to go ahead in August for just over four weeks.  It will be on the area close to the George Square Library on the north side of the events area.  (The events area is the section of the Meadows east of Middle Meadow Walk which has services installed.)

preparation of the management plan is well under way and the Meadows has been inspected with a view to being awarded a 'green flag' status.  The result will be announced later in the year.
Here is how Andrew Picken of the Evening News reported yesterday's decision.

Expenses

A few days ago I indicated a reduction in articles on expenses! I drew attention to my article on ConservativeHome about councillors' expenses in Scotland. Here is a follow up you might like to read. And here is one councillor who promised the electorate he would only draw 90% of the councillor's salary and does what he said he would.

Yesterday's full council meeting approved my call for detailed publication of Councillors' expense claims. If you have missed the recent discussions you can find councillors' expenses details here and here.

Preston Street primary picture

The Scotsman's online picture of the day (and on page 5 of the print edition) is of pupils Amina Davidson and Charlotte McLachlan of Preston Street Primary with Rabiya Choudhry. You can see today's Scotsman here and the picture here.

Thursday, 28 May 2009

Mentone Terr street party on Saturday

Between 4pm and 8pm on Saturday 30th Mentone Terrace will be closed between Moston and Glenorchy for their annual street party.

Newbattle Terr closed till Monday

Emergency repair to high voltage electricity cables has resulted in the closure of Newbattle Terrace between Canaan Lane and Whitehouse Loan. The road is expected to reopen by Monday 1st June

Wednesday, 27 May 2009

Human rights appeal by library attacker

Many will recall the horrific 1991 attack on an 11 year old girl near to Newington Library in 2001. Having been sentenced to 12 years at the time, the culprit  has been released early and is now seeking legal aid to challenge the conditions imposed on his early release.  His lawyers are founding on the European Convention of Human Rights.   No wonder confidence in the current Scottish judicial system is low.

Tuesday, 26 May 2009

Hope Terrace building future

I have been asked what is happening to the Scottish Natural Heritage building in Hope Terrace.

In August 2008 the premises were sold by SNH to Medina Sun Ltd and Kirkbride Investments. The Edinburgh Gazette of 28th November 2008 shows this company as going into administration. I am not sure what the position is with Kirkbride Investments - their office is given as International House, 16 Bell Lane, P.O. Box 872, Gibraltar. Strictly, they are not a UK company and I don't know more about them.

Monday, 25 May 2009

Another cycle crash in Mayfied Road

The junction of West Savile Terrace at Mayfield Road has witnessed 14 crashes involving cycle casualties in the last 10 years.   The last of these was this afternoon around 5pm when a cyclist was taken to the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary after a collision involving at least two cars.


This junction is currently under scrutiny from Transport experts who recently informally proposed to local councillors two suggested traffic management options.   The first is to create a well marked cycle lane on the west side with suitable markings and moving the central island in Mayfield Road. It is not certain how effective that would be and this option would need to be accompanied by measures to provide more security for pedestrians crossing the road in W Savile Terrace.  The second is to put automatic traffic signals on the junction.   That has more chance of reducing the collision rate and preventing crash injuries.  However it would make this cycle route less attractive, reduce air quality from vehicle pollution and generally reduce traffic flows in the area.

A further report is expected very soon from traffic engineers.  

This road is a key cycle route whose users include students cycling between George Square and Kings Buildings.   Pedestrians have reported particular difficulty in crossing the the West Savile Terrace arm of the junction though, until recently, there was no similar history of pedestrian casualties at the junction.

Sick Kids drop-in feature

Following the Sick Kids press release about their refurbished drop-in centre for parents and children, The Herald has produced a feature about centre at 21 Millerfield Place.

Councillors' expenses (one final time)

Here is the last post on expenses for a few days!   It is worth saying that the totals of councillor expenses seem modest.   Generally the rules on which the claims are based will stand scrutiny - though there is an element of confusion amongst councillors as to exactly what is included and what is not.    For example, when a councillor is attending an event on behalf of the Council it is not clear whether travel is charged to councillors' expenses consistently.   There are other anomalies.

Meanwhile, here, the Evening News reports my motion.

Saturday, 23 May 2009

Expenses: 2008/9 expenses announced

Yesterday the summary of expense costs per Edinburgh councillor for April 2008 to March 2009 was published.  You can find the table here in Excel or PDF format.


The lowest 10 are:
  1. Cllr Stuart McIvor (SNP, Inverleith) Nil
  2. Cllr Norma Hart (Lab, Liberton/Gilmerton) Nil
  3. Cllr Stephen Hawkins (Lib Dem, Portobello/Craigmillar)  £131
  4. Cllr Jeremy Balfour (Conservative, Corstorphine/Murrayfield) £232
  5. Cllr Cameron Rose (Conservative, Southside/Newington)  £240
  6. Cllr Iain Whyte (Conservative, Inverleith)  £281
  7. Cllr Mike Bridgeman (SNP, Portobello/Craigmillar)  £296
  8. Cllr Ron Cairns (SNP, Pentland Hills) £296)
  9. Cllr Allan Jackson (Conservative, Forth) £349
  10. Cllr Jim Lowrie (Lib Dem, Sighthill/Gorgie) £366

 And the highest 10:
  1. Cllr Phil Wheeler (Lib Dem, Corstorphine/Murrayfield)  £2765
  2. Cllr Tom Buchanan (SNP, Liberton/Gilmerton)  £2619
  3. Cllr Steve Cardownie (SNP, Forth)  £2455
  4. Cllr Paul Edie (Lib Dem, Corstorphine/Murrayfield)  £2436
  5. Cllr Gordon Mackenzie (Lib Dem,  Southside/Newington) £1955
  6. Cllr Alistair Paisley (Conservative, Pentland Hills)  £1908 
  7. Cllr David Beckett (SNP, City Centre)  £1581
  8. Cllr Donald Wilson (Labour, Sighthill/Gorgie)   £1438
  9. Cllr Marilyne Maclaren (Lib Dem, Meadows/Morningside)   £1403
  10. Cllr Joanne Mowat (Conservative, City Centre)  £1327


Expenses scandal: What about councillors?

I thought you might like to see my councillors' expenses article published today on the Local Government pages of ConservativeHome.   My motion to next Thursday's meeting of Edinburgh Council can be found here (scroll down agenda to item 10.1).  The indications are the administration will support it.

Forged £20 notes appearing in local shops

Charity shops in Nicolson Street and the Newington corridor have been particularly targeted by criminals using forged non Scottish £20 notes.   Other shops have been caught out as well and police have been working on an early warning system to prevent further losses to local shops in the Southside.  The local paper has an article about this here.

Friday, 22 May 2009

Thursday, 21 May 2009

Ideas workshop for West Crosscauseway

The West Crosscauseway Association are holding an ideas workshop on 16th of June between 10am and 4pm. In 2007 they sponsored a project to transform the part of the street at the Buccleuch Street end. Now they are bringing local people together for an ideas workshop with a view to transforming West Crosscauseway permanently. If you want to be involved, contact Isobel via their website.

Meadows Festival on track 6th/7th June

After some delays the Meadows Festival is once again on track. It takes place on Saturday 6th and Sunday 7th June on the west Meadows. As always volunteers to help in varying roles from stewards to litter pickers are sought to help make this event a success. If you can help, contact volunteer co-ordinator Nikki Thomson on meadowsfestival@yahoo.co.uk with details of when they would be available and what they might like to do. There will be a meeting for volunteers at 5pm on Friday 5th June outside the Pavilion Cafe (beside the jawbone). The website this year can be found here.

Wednesday, 20 May 2009

Sick Kids drop-in centre celebrates

The Sick Kids drop in centre at 21 Millerfield Place celebrates its third anniversary today.  Details in this press release.

Preston Street GP faces charges

John McCallum, a GP based at a local surgery, faces charges after a neighbour dispute near his home in Merchiston.  More here.

Famous local resident born 22.5.1859

Friday marks 150 years since the birth of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. A series of events at the Royal College of Surgeons marks the anniversary. See here for more relevant information about this famous resident of the area. Born at 11 Picardy Place he also lived at Sciennes Hill Place, Argyle Park Terrace and George Square.

Alfie missing from Palmerston Road

Alfie has escaped. He has been known to climb walls or he could even have walked out of the gate. He tends to dig in slightly, or hide in the bushes, so that only the top of his shell is visible. He also tends to dig in when he can go no further ie. against a wall or fence. Archie is a tortoise and if you come across him contact someone at the Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council.

Tuesday, 19 May 2009

Briery Bauks good neighbour award

Tom Bonallo of Briery Bauks has been nominated for an Evening News Good Neighbour award. See here for the details.

Kebab Mahal takes curry award

The Irn Bru Scottish Curry Awards 2009 has given the Kebab Mahal in Nicolson Square top spot in the Take-away of the year category. Their victory was announced yesterday in Glasgow and Zahid Khan, the curry chef who opened the Kebab Mahal 30 years ago still runs the premises with his family.

Monday, 18 May 2009

Nicolson Square to be exclusion zone

Following complaints of antisocial behaviour in the newly refurbished Nicolson Square, it can be confirmed that the police and council are close to setting up an exclusion zone which give greater powers to move on the congregating drunks. This will be similar to that which was implemented several years ago in Hunter Square and was broadly successful in improving the atmosphere in the public square. Many local people have reported that with gatherings of 3 to 15 drunks loitering in the gardens at Nicolson Square the benches and grass become unsuitable for local people and children as a place of public resort.

Policing Sir Fred in Grange

The local paper has used a freedom of information request to prepare it's front page lead today. The item seeks to contrast the police resources spent on Sir Fred's broken windows with the poor solvency rate for vandalism in general. The line taken is that these police resources would have been better spent on more deserving people.

It is fair enough to ask the question - we do need to scrutinise the deployment of police resources. However when the Evening News reporter called me on Saturday, told me of the story and asked for a comment, I readily gave a comment - which clearly did not suit their story. I declined to criticise the police operation and noted there were good reasons why it seemed reasonable to me the police had devoted considerable resources to the incident.

  1. The breaking of the windows, which is a crime, predictably was swept up in a national media firestorm. For the police to have withdrawn would have been to invite an anarchic situation, with feeling running so high.
  2. From the email release on behalf of those responsible it appears they were part of an anarchy group. This or similar groups have a history of attacking property of public figures in Edinburgh. In an earlier incident the offices of Nigel Griffiths were trashed and similarly (outwith this ward) Alistair Darling's offices were damaged by an anarchic group. I may have little in common with Nigel politically but encouraging anarchists in their lawbreaking is not for me.
  3. For purely practical reasons the police would have looked stupid had they allowed this incident to escalate. There are many criticisms which can be made of the police priorities but this is not one of them. When will we see culprits for these crimes?

I have already posted on the need to get a proper balance in these situations.

Cameron Toll Centre proposals

It is 25 years since the Cameron Toll Shopping Centre was opened. The current owners have proposals to upgrade the centre which will come before the Council Planning Committee soon. You can see the application here. There will be an opportunity to hear the proposals from the developers at the Grange/Prestonfield Community Council this coming Wednesday (20th May) at 7:30pm. This will be preceded by the Community Council's AGM at 7pm. Both meetings are open to the public.

More on stunt biking in the Meadows

Here is another report on the activities of Danny MacAskill who specialises in stunt riding in the centre of Edinburgh.  Access the YouTube clip here.

Cricket in the Grange

Carlton Cricket Club in Grange Loan, beat Watsonians on Saturday.   See here for details of the match. 

Saturday, 16 May 2009

Expenses: Edinburgh Councillors

The administration on Edinburgh Council has denied my request to publish full details of councillors' expenses.


Councils are obliged by law to publish costs of councillors expenses.   The expenses summary for 2007/8 for Edinburgh Councillors can be found online here (though it is very difficult to find - there are no obvious links from the council's home page, from the register of interests pages of individual councillors or from the Council's publication schedule under the Freedom of Information Act).

However, the expenses summary, published in May every year for the 12 months to the end of the preceding March, is just that - a summary.  So last month, before the present revelations led by the Daily Telegraph, I called for publication on the internet of full expenses claimed by Edinburgh councillors.  My call was reported in the Evening News here and in the council papers here - see item 11.1.

However, the Lord Provost ruled that because summary information was already published on the Council website, my motion was incompetent, failing to accept my argument that my motion was to publish full information.   That is simply not an acceptable response and I expect to submit an amended motion to the May council meeting.   To date informal discussions suggest the Administration may be willing to accept the publication of some detail of expenses claimed.  

The Lord Provost in his ruling clearly did not understand the implications of my motion in the current climate and I am sure will accept it in slightly amended form when it is resubmitted to the next meeting of the full council later this month.

Wednesday, 13 May 2009

Southside Community Council AGM

Southside Community Council meets this evening between 7 and 9pm in the Nelson Hall, Spittalfield Crescent.

Archers Hall proposals approved

This morning the Planning Committee approved the proposals for development of at the Archers Hall in Buccleuch Street at Boroughloch. You can find the background details on this earlier post and more information in the links there.

Tuesday, 12 May 2009

Prestonfield House Hotel wins award

Another award for Prestonfield House Hotel this week, with chef John MacMahon picking up the silver medal for hotel chef of the year at the Scottish Chef Awards in Glasgow on Sunday night.

More details here.

Prestonfield Avenue hit-and-run

Police are appealing for witnesses to a hit-and-run incident in Prestonfield Avenue on Monday evening, in which a 64 year old woman was injured. BBC report the story here.

Friday, 8 May 2009

Community Council Backgreens push

The Edinburgh Community Backgreens Association is becoming increasingly active amongst the tenements on the Southside of Edinburgh. After a recent launch in the area their community gardener will be speaking at the Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council meeting next Wednesday evening at 7:30pm. See here for details of that meeting.

Thursday, 7 May 2009

S Clerk St Community Art Exhibition

The King's Hall in South Clerk Street will host an exhibition bringing together more than 20 local artists - using painting, photography, illustration, sculpture, card design, jewellery, floristry and printmaking. And there is a cafe and live music. The hours are 11am to 5pm Saturday 9th and Sunday 10th May. See here for more details.

Wednesday, 6 May 2009

Meadows: Events report available

The long awaited report which will be the backdrop for management arrangements for events in the Meadows is now available here. This will go to the Policy and Strategy committee on Tuesday 12th May.

Many have been in touch with me about this. There has been growing concern about overuse of parts of the Meadows in recent years - particularly the section designated for events just east of Middle Meadow Walk - resulting in ground conditions failing to get enough time to recover. Of course, the Meadows is a jewel in the crown of Edinburgh and the Meadows is a fantastic venue for events. In fact, the Meadows is an important part of Edinburgh's reputation as a leading events and festival city. Although it has taken a while to get to this stage (as the report makes clear) we now need get management rules in place which give clear guidance.

Council officials have been negotiating with potential users and events managers in recent months and there has been considerable uncertainty for event organisers. Nonetheless a number of large events have been moved for this year (Taste of Edinburgh and the Moonwalk).

Tuesday, 5 May 2009

Sciennes Grange CPZ revision due July

The Head of Transport agreed to bring forward a review of the implementation and effects of the S1 controlled parking zone to the next meeting of the Transport Committee (28th July). It is understood this will look at merging S1 with the parts of zones 7 and 8 between S1 and the Meadows which is seen as forming a natural boundary. It is also expected that it will look at the pressures created by S1 on the Findhorn Place and other boundaries of S1, and on the usage of road space for parking within S1.

S6 CPZ proposal abandoned

The proposal to introduce a CPZ in the area south of S1 (generally the Grange to Dalkeith Road and to the South Sub) was abandoned this morning at the Transport Committee. A commitment was given to review local pressure points with a view to reporting back localised options - rather than a full blown CPZ. The report considered today can be found here and it should be noted that the recommendation is made on financial and local opposition grounds.

It was noted, however, that the problems areas thrown up in the initial consultation had not been dealt with before the scheme was put out for consultation. This resulted in many of the respondents, who were broadly in favour of the scheme, commenting negatively on a part of it. This resulted in 'opposition' to the scheme as being a key reason for abandoning it.

CPZ proposals require to be self funding and the report expressed doubts that the cost to implement the scheme would not be recouped.

The committee did approve a motion to look again at the pressure points 9especially on the periphery of S1 and to report within 6-8 months. See next post for revisions to S1.

Prestonfield CPZ proposal binned

At the meeting of the Transport committee this morning the proposal to impose a controlled parking zone throughout Prestonfield was abandoned. The report (click here and view particularly appendix 5) indicated that the majority of comments were against the proposal but highlighted the pressures in Kilmaurs, Kirkhill and Priestfield. It was agreed that transport officials would look again at this area for any measures which might alleviate the current pressures. A report can be expected in six to eight months on such options.

The main reason for abandoning the proposal was the views from the consultation and doubts that it could be made to be cost neutral. You can read the full report at the link above.

Monday, 4 May 2009

Great Edinburgh Run success

For the sporting side of the event see here for the win of Kenyan Micah Kogo.

For the Scotsman's view of the run see here.

Saturday, 2 May 2009

Prestonfield CPZ proposal - summary

  • The report with the results of the public consultation and survey goes to the Transport Committee on Tuesday 5th May.
  • The report recommends not proceeding with formal proposals to introduce controlled parking in the Prestonfield area (bounded by the railway line to the South, Dalkeith Road to the West, Romero Place, Abden House and the Park to the North and the golf course and Morgan playing fields to the East).
  • 214 individual responses from 1681 households were received.
  • 53 indicated broad support for a CPZ and 161 were opposed to the introduction of such controls. 47 of those against were from the Priestfield/Kirkhill/Kilmaurs area. (The report analyses responses from this area separately but concludes that if controls were only applied here there would be a knock on effect which would require a future CPZ in the southern part.)
  • Roughly two thirds of the responses were against a CPZ extension.
  • The parking survey in December concluded (tentatively) that of 1427 vehicles parked, 55% belonged to residents, 25% were visitors and 17% were commuters.

The Committee will decide how to proceed on Tuesday but it is clear from this report that there will not be a CPZ in the Prestonfield area in the near future. There is now a need to look at the pinch points in Kilmaurs/Priestfield/Kirkhill areas to see if there are viable alternatives to reduce the pressure currently being experienced.

The full report and map of the area affected can be found at Appendix 5 of this report.

Friday, 1 May 2009

St Leonards PC admits charges

Suspended PC Anna Wong, based at St Leonards Police Station, has admitted charges of accessing personal information on police computers. See here for further details though the article does not reveal precisely what she did which breached the Data Protection regulations.

Odeon debate

A couple of weeks ago there was a letter in the Scotsman which is part of a campaign to have Historic Scotland call in for full enquiry the decision last October by the Planning Committee about the Odeon. On 29th October the Planning Committee approved a proposal which would retain the Art Deco frontage but allow the auditorium to be demolished to enable a boutique hotel and art centre. For previous correspondence in the Scotsman on this issue see here and here. This last letter was published on 16th April and today the Scotsman has published (eventually) my response which I append in full below.

IN the next few weeks, Historic Scotland may decide the fate of the former Odeon cinema in Clerk Street, Edinburgh. Or perhaps they will continue the saga that has now gone on for six years.
And that is the point. The community has for six years had a potential asset in its midst which has lain virtually unused. This is planning blight – or more accurately, listed building blight.

The auditorium, which the current campaigners seek to save (Letters, 16 April) is B-listed and worthy of retention, but not at any cost. In this case the shadow of procedural delay and uncertainty has an opportunity cost which is to the detriment of the city.
The campaigners seek to correct an alleged wrong in process. And there is room for argument on the predicted future economic viability of the site with the auditorium retained. Nonetheless, I have viewed the documents on which they apparently found their arguments and am far from convinced they lead to the conclusions they seek to draw. I believe it is time to bring this lengthy procedural review to an end and endorse the decision which has already been taken by the planning committee.
(CLLR) CAMERON ROSE

10,000 set for Great Edinburgh Run

The Great Edinburgh Run is a major event on Sunday 3rd. Many of the participants will be raising money for charity. Click on the link above and you will get a video of last year's event as well as more information about route and timing.

CPZ reports published

The reports on proposed controlled parking zones have now been published (links below). for consideration at the Transport, Infrastructure and Environment committee which meets at 10am on 5th May in the City Chambers. More comment will follow later.

  • S6 area (this is the Grange area to the south of S1 up to approximately the South Sub).
  • Prestonfield (this is the pre proposal consultation result and can be found at Appendix 5 if you follow the link)

Swine flu - sources of official info

Doubtless there will be some locally who have been in contact with affected areas of people. Here are sources of official information about the outbreak: